What Are FAT and SAT? How to Plan Factory and Site Acceptance Tests

  • Blog
  • What Are FAT and SAT? How to Plan Factory and Site Acceptance Tests
What Are FAT and SAT? How to Plan Factory and Site Acceptance Tests
Share

What Are FAT and SAT? How to Plan Factory and Site Acceptance Tests

Table of Contents

  • What is FAT?
  • What is SAT?
  • Difference Between FAT and SAT
  • What is Checked During FAT?
  • What is Checked During SAT?
  • Preparation of Test Protocols
  • Management of Punch List Items
  • Relationship with Qualification
  • Common Mistakes
  • A Practical Checklist for FAT and SAT
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Conclusion

In industrial projects, the delivery of equipment to the site does not mean the work is finished. It must also be demonstrated that the equipment was manufactured in accordance with specifications, operates as expected, and is properly installed on site. This verification is typically carried out in two stages: Factory Acceptance Testing (FAT) and Site Acceptance Testing (SAT). In this article, we cover what these two tests are, the differences between them, and how they should be planned.

What is FAT?

FAT is the testing of equipment at the manufacturer's facility prior to shipment, conducted with the participation of the customer or their representative. The goal is to demonstrate that the equipment has been built according to specifications and performs its core functions before being dispatched to the site. Deficiencies identified during FAT can be rectified much faster and at a lower cost at the manufacturing facility.

What is SAT?

SAT involves testing the equipment at the customer's site after installation, integrated with its actual physical connections and utility systems. Aspects that cannot be tested during FAT—such as integration with site piping, actual utility conditions, communication with other systems, and the accuracy of the site installation—are verified during SAT.

Difference Between FAT and SAT

  • Location: FAT is performed at the manufacturer's facility; SAT is conducted at the customer's site.
  • Timing: FAT takes place prior to shipment; SAT occurs following site installation.
  • Scope: FAT focuses on the standalone equipment; SAT verifies the equipment's operation integrated with site systems.
  • Conditions: FAT utilizes simulated utilities and connections where necessary; SAT uses actual operating conditions.

The two tests are not alternatives to one another. A well-planned FAT shortens the duration of SAT, while SAT addresses aspects that could not be verified during FAT.

What is Checked During FAT?

  • Documentation review: drawings, material certificates, weld logs, calibration records
  • Dimensional and visual inspection: nozzle locations, surface finish quality, labeling
  • Pressure and leak tightness testing
  • Mechanical function testing: agitator rotation, valve actuation, pump operation
  • Electrical and automation testing: signal checks, alarms, interlocks, operator interface screens
  • Surface roughness measurement and internal surface inspection via borescope where required

What is Checked During SAT?

  • Post-transport damage inspection and verification of installation against drawings
  • Verification of site piping, electrical, and utility connections
  • Functional testing under actual water, steam, compressed air, and electrical conditions
  • Communication testing with other equipment and the central control system
  • Execution of cleaning and sterilization cycles such as CIP and SIP
  • Closure of open punch list items remaining from FAT

Preparation of Test Protocols

The success of FAT and SAT depends on test protocols prepared in advance and approved by the customer. The protocol outlines the objective, methodology, acceptance criteria, required test equipment, and data recording fields for each test. Any deviation from the protocol during testing is recorded and a resolution path defined. Tests conducted without approved protocols can lead to disputes later in the project.

A recommended approach when preparing protocols is mapping every requirement in the project specifications to a corresponding test step. This traceability matrix confirms that no requirement is omitted from testing and serves as a strong foundation during customer audits.

Management of Punch List Items

Nearly every FAT and SAT reveals minor deficiencies or points requiring correction. These items are compiled into a punch list, with a responsible party and target completion date assigned to each. The criticality of each item is also classified: certain items must be closed before shipment or commissioning, while others may be addressed at a subsequent project stage. Regularly tracking this list prevents minor items from dragging on until project completion.

Relationship with Qualification

In pharmaceutical and biotechnology projects, FAT and SAT serve as foundational precursor steps in the qualification process. Well-documented FAT and SAT results can be leveraged as references during Installation Qualification (IQ) and Operational Qualification (OQ) without repeating the tests. This approach avoids redundant testing and streamlines the project timeline. To achieve this, FAT and SAT protocols must be drafted in alignment with the expectations of the qualification team.

Common Mistakes

Treating FAT as merely a visual inspection, preparing test protocols at the last minute, sending representatives without decision-making authority to tests, and failing to record open punch items are the most common mistakes. These errors result in issues surfacing on site that could have been resolved far more easily at the factory. Having authorized personnel from both technical and quality roles on the testing team ensures decisions can be made directly during testing.

A Practical Checklist for FAT and SAT

To maximize efficiency, preparation must begin well before the day of testing. Prerequisites include having the protocol approved prior to the test date, receiving confirmation from the manufacturer that the equipment is fully ready for testing, ensuring calibration of required measurement tools is current, and compiling complete documentation. Clarifying team composition, decision-making authority, and resource allocation ahead of time is equally essential.

Following testing, the report must be finalized promptly, signatures collected, and the punch list distributed to relevant teams. Failing to document decisions made during testing in writing can lead to conflicting interpretations later. Consequently, the test report should record not only the test results, but also decisions made and accepted deviations.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is FAT required for every piece of equipment?

No. FAT is typically conducted for complex, critical, or automated equipment. For simple equipment, documentation reviews and site inspections may suffice. The decision should be guided by a risk and cost assessment.

Can FAT be conducted remotely?

Certain tests can be monitored remotely via video links and digital recordings. However, on-site attendance is generally preferred for aspects requiring physical inspection.

Who manages the SAT?

SAT is typically executed by the equipment supplier or installation contractor, while the customer witnesses the execution and approves the results. Role distribution should be clearly defined in the contract beforehand.

FAT and SAT are two complementary verification steps demonstrating that equipment and systems function as intended. Executed with pre-approved protocols, clear acceptance criteria, and well-managed punch lists, they safeguard both quality and project schedules. Learn more about how we manage testing processes in our turnkey projects by contacting us.